santamargherita

Categoria: The WineNews Corner

Firenze - 10 Gennaio 2008, ore 15:42

A STUDY DISCOVERS THE TOP ITALIAN RESTAURANTS THAT ALL OF THE TOP ITALIAN FOOD GUIDES AGREE ON. LE CALANDRE, ENOTECA PINCHIORRI AND GAMBERO ROSSO HEAD THE LIST

Picking a restaurant isn’t so easy these days. And, first, one needs to pick the right guide. There is obviously the Michelin guide, a prestigious name with long and international experience; wine lovers enjoy the Gambero Rosso restaurant guide; and then there are also the Espresso, Veronelli and Touring Club Italiano that are considered the top guides to Italian dining. But, among these guides, preferences vary and there isn’t always a unanimous decision on Italy’s restaurants.
The “Italia a Tavola Network”, however, has managed to cross examine all of the guides to come up with the restaurants that received the highest votes all around.
When comparing the votes from all of these guides - whether they were stars, or cents, or points - the highest marks for Italy’s restaurants went to Massimiliano Alajmo of Le Calandre, Annie Feolde of Enoteca Pinchiorri, and Fulvio Pierangelini of Gambero Rosso.
Receiving very similar scores in all five of the “super guides”, these three historic restaurants, famous also abroad, are the only three that all of the experts agree upon.
After this triad of excellence, the opinions of the rest of Italy’s restaurants are discordant and very mixed. And this could just be a good example of critics doing their job well. Though there are some parameters that must be followed when expressing an opinion, in the end, each critic still has his own personal taste that will never quite be the same as any other’s.
But, when reviewing these guides, there is another fundamental element that cannot be ignored: it is most probable that the judgment made by some guides does not take into consideration only the quality of the food.
Though Italy has an ancient and distinguished culture and tradition of cooking, the number of its Michelin three-star restaurants never seems to increase (there are only five: Le Calandre in Rubano - Pd; Al Sorriso in Soriso - No; Dal Pescatore in Canneto sull’Oglio - Mn; Enoteca Pinchiorri in Florence; La Pergola in the Hotel Hilton in Rome), while other countries like Germany, Japan, and Portugal have long surpassed Italy’s meagre number of three-star restaurants.
Among the various explanations for this is the fact that, at least for the French guide, there is also a lot of weight put on the ambience of a restaurant. So it may be that Italian restaurants might need to do a little remodelling if they want to catch up…

banner Cecchi English Corner

Altre News



TUTTI GLI ARTICOLI
Seguici su Twitter

WineMeteo

velature sparse Aglianico del Vulture:
Barile (PZ)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
quasi sereno Alto Adige:
Bolzano (BZ)

Temp: 14°
Precip: -
quasi sereno Alto Adige:
Appiano sulla strada del vino (BZ)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
sereno Amarone:
Negrar (VR)

Temp: 14°
Precip: -
nuvoloso Barbaresco:
Barbaresco (CN)

Temp: 11°
Precip: -
sereno Bardolino:
Bardolino (VR)

Temp: 15°
Precip: -
nuvoloso Barolo:
Barolo (CN)

Temp: 11°
Precip: -
variabile Bolgheri:
Castagneto Carducci (LI)

Temp: 17°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Brunello di Montalcino:
Montalcino (SI)

Temp: 15°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Chianti Classico:
San Casciano in Val di Pesa (FI)

Temp: 16°
Precip: -
nuvoloso Cinque Terre:
La Spezia (SP)

Temp: 17°
Precip: -
sereno Cirò:
Ciro' (KR)

Temp: 14°
Precip: -
sereno Colli Orientali del Friuli:
Manzano (UD)

Temp: 14°
Precip: -
sereno Collio:
San Floriano del collio (GO)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
velature sparse Est Est Est:
Montefiascone (VT)

Temp: 16°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Etna:
Castiglione di Sicilia (CT)

Temp: 16°
Precip: -
parz nuvoloso Franciacorta:
Erbusco (BS)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
velature sparse Frascati:
Frascati (RM)

Temp: 18°
Precip: -
sereno Friulano:
Cormons (GO)

Temp: 14°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Greco di Tufo:
Tufo (AV)

Temp: 16°
Precip: -
variabile Lacrima di Morro d’Alba:
Morro d'alba (AN)

Temp: 12°
Precip: -
nuvoloso Lambrusco:
Modena (MO)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
quasi sereno Molise:
Campomarino (CB)

Temp: 16°
Precip: -
quasi sereno Montepulciano d'Abruzzo:
Chieti (CH)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
parz nuvoloso Morellino:
Scansano (GR)

Temp: 17°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Nobile di Montepulciano:
Montepulciano (SI)

Temp: 15°
Precip: -
nebbia e schiarite Orvieto:
Orvieto (TR)

Temp: 14°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Primitivo di Manduria:
Manduria (TA)

Temp: 17°
Precip: -
sereno Prosecco:
Valdobbiadene (TV)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Rosso Piceno:
Offida (AP)

Temp: 12°
Precip: -
sereno con  foschia Sagrantino:
Montefalco (PG)

Temp: 15°
Precip: -
variabile Sangiovese di Romagna:
Bertinoro (FC)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
velature sparse Sardegna:
Alghero (SS)

Temp: 23°
Precip: -
variabile Sardegna:
Cagliari (CA)

Temp: 21°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Sicilia:
Menfi (AG)

Temp: 20°
Precip: -
velature sparse Sicilia:
Pantelleria (TP)

Temp: 20°
Precip: -
sereno Sicilia:
Marsala (TP)

Temp: 20°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Soave:
Soave (VR)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
variabile Suvereto:
Suvereto (LI)

Temp: 18°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Taurasi:
Taurasi (AV)

Temp: 15°
Precip: -
nebbia e schiarite Torgiano:
Torgiano (PG)

Temp: 14°
Precip: -
sereno Trentino:
Lavis (TN)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
sereno Trentino:
Mezzocorona (TN)

Temp: 12°
Precip: -
sereno Trentino:
San Michele all'Adige (TN)

Temp: 12°
Precip: -
velature sparse Valle d'Aosta:
Aosta (AO)

Temp: 17°
Precip: -
velature lievi Valtellina:
Sondrio (SO)

Temp: 15°
Precip: -
variabile Verdicchio:
Jesi (AN)

Temp: 13°
Precip: -
parz. nuvoloso Vernaccia:
San Gimignano (SI)

Temp: 15°
Precip: -
Mezzacorona

Non solo vino
I capolavori dell'agroalimentare d'Italia

Leggi tutti gli articoli

Spazio promozionale

Panorama aziende

capraihome.png

ARNALDO CAPRAI

Il Sagrantino di Montefalco alla ribalta internazionale

castellobanfi.png

CASTELLO BANFI

In Toscana fra tradizione e innovazione

umanironchihome.png

UMANI RONCHI

L'esperienza marchigiana proiettata verso il futuro